Where to enjoy the best pizza in East Sussex: La Casa Pizzeria in Nutley 📍

Authentic Italian food in Nutley

Looking for a spot in East Sussex where every bite takes you straight to Italy? At La Casa Pizzeria in the heart of Nutley, we’ve created a place where tradition, fresh ingredients and warm hospitality come together for a truly authentic Italian dining experience.

Read on to discover why many consider us the home of the best pizza in East Sussex.

Why East Sussex loves La Casa Pizzeria

The secret lies in authenticity.

• The Pizza Della Casa, topped with Parma ham, parmesan shavings and fresh rocket, is elegance in simplicity.

• The classic Margherita, with its slow-fermented dough, homemade tomato base and creamy mozzarella, proves perfection can be simple.

• For a touch of spice, the Pizza Piccante with pepperoni or with hot honey is a local favourite.

Here, every pizza is made with respect for tradition and quality ingredients.

Ingredients with a story: from Italy to Nutley

At La Casa, food is more than flavour – it’s storytelling.

• The Spaghetti Carbonara, with Italian bacon and creamy parmesan sauce, is a timeless favourite.

• The Lasagna della Casa, made with slow-cooked bolognese, is the ultimate comfort food.

• Vegetarians love the Penne alla Norma, with aubergines and tomatoes, or the Quattro Formaggi Pizza with four Italian cheeses.

• Seafood lovers enjoy the Linguine alle Vongole with clams and white wine or the Risotto Marinara with fresh seafood.

💡 Fun fact: Tiramisù translates to “lift me up” in Italian – and our Pistachio Tiramisù does exactly that.

More than just pizza

• Starters like Calamari Fritti or the Antipasto Italiano are perfect for sharing.

• Pair a Prosciutto e Funghi Pizza with a glass of Chianti, or enjoy a Risotto alla Genovese with a crisp Pinot Grigio.

• Finish with desserts like Lemon Cheesecake or Profiteroles.

The warm, welcoming atmosphere makes La Casa Pizzeria perfect for date nights, family dinners or celebrations.

FAQs

Where can I eat the best pizza in East Sussex?👉 In Nutley, La Casa Pizzeria offers classics like the Margherita and specialities like the Cipolla e Capra.

Do you have vegetarian options?👉 Yes, from Penne alla Norma to the Vegetariana Pizza.

What dessert do you recommend?👉 The Pistachio Tiramisù is a must, alongside the Tartufo Classico.

Do you offer takeaway?👉 Yes, order online with our Takeaway service.

✨ Book your table today and taste the most authentic pizza in East Sussex.

Reserve here