What to Order at La Casa Nutley: A First-Timer’s Guide

La Casa
Jun 1
2 min read

New to La Casa Nutley? Here's What to Order First

Walking into an Italian restaurant for the first time can be exciting and overwhelming. With so many delicious choices on the menu, where do you even start? If you’re new to La Casa Nutley, we’re here to help you experience the very best of what we have to offer.

Table at La Casa Nutley with a pizza, pasta, wine, and tiramisu served beautifully.

Start with Something to Share

Begin your meal the Italian way—with something to share. Our Antipasto Italiano is the perfect introduction: a platter of mixed Italian cured meats, ideal for setting the tone of a relaxed, flavourful dining experience. It's simple, savoury, and just right to awaken your appetite.

Can’t Go Wrong with a Classic Pizza

Our Margherita is a timeless favourite, simple yet full of flavour, with a tomato sauce base and creamy mozzarella, baked to perfection in our wood-fired oven. Fancy something with a bit more personality? Try the Tonno Cipolla, topped with tuna, red onion and olives for a bold, Mediterranean-inspired twist.

View our full pizza selection here: La Casa Nutley Menu

Craving Pasta? Here Are a Few Favourites

At La Casa Nutley, our pasta is made with tradition, care, and plenty of flavour.

Spaghetti Bolognese – A comforting classic, made with 100% minced beef in our rich, homemade tomato sauce.
Linguine al Pollo e Pesto – Tender diced chicken and cherry tomatoes tossed in a creamy pesto sauce for a savoury, satisfying dish.
Linguine Marinara – A seafood lover’s dream, featuring a medley of mixed seafood with cherry tomatoes in a garlic and white wine sauce.

Each plate is freshly prepared using time-honoured Italian techniques that bring every ingredient to life.

Don’t Forget Dessert!

End your meal on a sweet note with one of our indulgent, house-made desserts:

Tiramisu – A classic Italian favourite made in-house with coffee and liqueur-soaked savoiardi biscuits, layered with mascarpone cream and dusted with cocoa powder.
Cheesecake al Limone – A crisp biscuit base topped with lemon and mascarpone cheesecake, finished with roasted flaked almonds and a swirl of lemon curd.
Tartufo Classico – A rich, creamy gelato ball with a marsala wine centre, coated in crushed hazelnuts and cocoa powder—perfect for those who love a touch of decadence.

The perfect finish to your La Casa experience.

Pair It With the Right Wine

Ask our staff for wine recommendations! We offer a thoughtfully curated list of imported Italian wines to pair with your meal, from light and crisp whites to bold reds.